Product Picks

New House Color!!

We just passed the one year mark here in Arizona. What a year it’s been! There, for sure, have been some hard moments, and we miss parts of living in the city like crazy, but overall, we’re so happy and grateful for this past year. Mostly, it has been wonderful to live so close to…

We just passed the one year mark here in Arizona. What a year it’s been! There, for sure, have been some hard moments, and we miss parts of living in the city like crazy, but overall, we’re so happy and grateful for this past year. Mostly, it has been wonderful to live so close to family and of course I’ve loved getting to turn this house upside down! I can’t believe how much has changed since last July. The exterior was the most recent big change and I’m so happy with how it turned out!

 photo 41.jpg

Benjamin Moore, a company I love and support whole-heartedly, saw that we were planning to paint our house and reached out about donating the paint. What an AMAZING help that was! The house needed a ton of prep work before the paint, and we made some big changes to the exterior structures with a contractor, so the labor alone ended up taking most of our exterior budget. Getting to work with Benjamin Moore on the paint was a dream come true! :) But I’ll get to that in a minute. Here’s the story of how the exterior of our house has changed this year, and a few plans for finishing up.

 photo 1DSC_0348.jpg

Remember when the house looked like this? Gingerbread everywhere. Cream body and brown trim. Black, scary sun shades on all the windows (which are helpful for keeping out the sun, but man, are they UGLY!).

 photo 1DSC_0350.jpg

 photo IMG_4572.jpg

The first big project was changing out the front door. It’s hard to show in pictures just how much of a transformation this was! The old door was only 80″ tall, which felt so squatty with the tall vaulted entrance. Here’s the post on changing out the door.
 photo 1DSC_0351.jpg
We chose a 9.5′ tall double door. It fit the vertical space much better, but the door was blocked in the front by the weird front facade area.
 photo wDSC_0416.jpg

 photo aDSC_0425.jpg

My original thoughts were to just remove the front panel and open everything up all the way to the roof basically.
 photo wDSC_0420copy.jpg

But after we opened it up, the proportions felt so weird again! Too much was exposed, although, I was loving how much light was streaming in to the entry after getting rid of that partition piece!

 photo IMG_4879.jpg

Our contractor was nervous about losing the cross beam altogether as well, even though it wasn’t technically the load-bearing beam. So we came up with an idea to bump up the beam and add angled beams in too, which we would mimic all around the exterior of the house, where all the gingerbread used to be.

 photo IMG_4890.jpg

All the turned columns were replaced with chunky square beams and instantly everything felt more modern and more balanced.

 photo IMG_5064.jpg

 photo vIMG_5049.jpg

Once the exterior structural changes were almost done I went to my local Benjamin Moore store (Color Wheel on Stapley and Main) and looked at swatches for a good long while. I talked to them about different paint lines too and got their advice on that and finishes.

 photo IMG_7481.jpg

Benjamin Moore has so many wonderful colors it was tricky to pick a favorite for the house. I was drawn to the greeny grays the most and picked up a couple of chips and even a few sample pots to put up.

 photo IMG_7486.jpg

 photo IMG_4727.jpg

I put this photo up on Instagram for a reader vote. It seemed pretty split, which I expected. They’re all great colors! (Top to bottom: Fieldstone, Desert Twilight, Rockport Gray)

 photo IMG_4764.jpg

I really tried hard to make it not be the name the put me over the edge, but Desert Twilight (2137-40) was my favorite from the get-go. It was a little more green than I originally thought I’d want, but more and more I was in love with the shade and the idea of a greeny gray house. (Or at least I didn’t want a color with very blue undertones and I felt like my other top choices swung more blue). I put up a big sample on the front and the back of the house, so we could see what Desert Twilight did at different times of day.

 photo zIMG_5257.jpg

 photo bIMG_5053.jpg

I was a little apprehensive to make the final call, but I knew I’d love the color, especially once all that icky brown color was gone.

We chose to use the Aura exterior line in a Satin finish for both the body and the trim. My Benjamin Moore store said there’s nothing like it on the market that resists color fading and paint deterioration as well, which were both problems we could see the house has had in the past. My wonderful team of painters (Eagle Painting) loved the product and commented multiple times about the quality of the paint. They were super impressed with the coverage.

 photo IMG_7990.jpg
It was an exciting day when the painters sprayed the first coat of Aura on the back of the house! So pretty! So dramatic!
 photo zIMG_7507.jpg
 photo IMG_7503.jpg
 photo IMG_5586.jpg
The Aura paint is actually self-priming, so we didn’t need to use a primer on the back at all, but the front of the house gets a lot of full sun and there had been some damage from the elements. And since I wanted to paint out the weird shake shingles on the front of the house, the painters decided it would be a good idea to spray a coat of primer on the front. I knew the shake would never be a consistent, solid color the way that the siding looks, but I think the layer of primer helped even out the shake shingles. 
 photo IMG_5740.jpg
I think painting the shake out helped unify the choppy look of the house so much! I almost painted out the brick for the same reason, but I think I’m glad we kept the brick as-is for now. It was tricky to find a stopping point with the brick and I didn’t want to paint the floors or the fencing.
 photo 47.jpg
We might figure out something to do with the brick down the road, but for now I think the new house color is in harmony with the tones of the brick. Such an improvement!
 photo 42.jpg
As soon as the white trim went on, I finally felt like I could catch my breath and let go of my worries about this project! It looked SO much more fresh with the dark trim gone!
 photo 44.jpg
We chose White Dove (OC-17) for the trim and Onyx (2133-10) for the doors. All Aura, all satin.
 photo 48.jpg
We decided to keep the front door red in the end. I love how it looks against the Desert Twilight color! I was worried it would look Christmas-y, but it really doesn’t. I actually think the red tones down the green a bit too.
 photo IMG_5818.jpg
So, I’m sure you noticed, but we still have a way to go with the exterior of the house before we can call it good. We’re saving our pennies right now so we can replace the roof next spring. It’s expensive and not fun to spend that kind of money, but we’ve known about it and it is what it is. In the shorter term, we’re going to have a mason come out and fix some of our broken bricks and then add matching brick to the bases of the two new columns flanking the front door. 
 photo 43.jpg
Looking down the road maybe a year or two, I’d like to change up the landscaping. Not sure with what, but something less twisty and curvy and fussy would be my preference. But truly, I am SO happy with all the changes we’ve accomplished in only a year’s time! Every single one of our neighbors has stopped by to say how much they love it too and the validation feels great! :)
 photo IMG_4572.jpg
 photo 45.jpg
And OF COURSE, thank you, thank you, thank you to the wonderful people at Benjamin Moore, both local and corporate, for helping us to transform our home! We could not be more happy with the product or the outcome. :)
 photo 41.jpg
Join the Conversation

68 thoughts on “New House Color!!

  1. Thanks for your input guys, but I think we're going to leave the brick for now! I promised my husband I'd let us live with it for a while. :)

    What I'd really like to do is a tinted fill over the mortar lines, but we'll see what ends up happening.


  2. Jenny, I think you can paint the brick on the house and NOT worry about the brick in the landscape and walkway. Just look at the brick walls and walk as landscape components. Everything looks fabulous – and painting the brick on the house would make it even better, imho.

  3. Thanks for your input guys, but I think we're going to leave the brick for now! I promised my husband I'd let us live with it for a while. :)

    What I'd really like to do is a tinted fill over the mortar lines, but we'll see what ends up happening.


  4. Wow, it looks fabulous! I love the color! I think I would paint the brick a darker gray if it were my house, and possibly consider painting the trim around the front door in the onyx color, just to outline it. Beautiful transformation! I bet your neighbors are super happy.

  5. I'm enjoying following your progress. Despite following along, I can't believe all that you have done in just one year! The exterior improvements are fantastic- the color is great, the new front doors are perfect and the change to the area over the door (not sure what to call that) is incredible. You have breathed new life into an older home. I'm sure the neighbors are very appreciative. I was wondering if you had considered removing the shingles and replacing them with siding or even board and batten. They seem to be the only remaining Victorian detail. Can't wait to see what you do with the landscape.

  6. Having had our house painted in June I can feel your excitement! We wanted the color of wet cement, and where we live the colors were skewing either too blue / battleship-y (as in dead), or too brown. So I found a true artist (Shane) at a paint store (Lucas Paint in Denver) twenty+ miles from my home and together he and I came up with the perfect blend — it has a lot of green in it to counteract the blue / purple hue of the light up here (Rocky Mtns), and it truly mimics wet cement. I'd previously lacquered our front door / sidelights and windowboxes black (when our house was BM's Rockport Gray — too taupe), so kept those, but painted the doors in the back of the house BM's Gentle Violet and man is it RIGHT; like yours, our house also has a fair amount of brick; unlike yours, ours is tumbled and more muted in color. (that's the way the house came) The trim is, like yours, bright white, and I love it. LOVE it! So excited for you as I am so excited for us the transformation of our homes' exteriors.

    1. I know this post is old but I am having exact same issue and am also seeking a wet cement paint color…I used to live in Colorado ironically and understand the sun issue …would you be so kind as to share your paint formula? thanks so very much!

  7. LOVE IT! You have such an eye for color. The revised entry is awesome!

    And I agree painting the brick will show off the architectural detail of the house.

    Gorgeous home, Jenny!!!

  8. The new paint color looks amazing; I wouldn't paint the brick, but I would probably be thinking about white washing it in the future.

  9. I absolutely LOVE the red door! It doesn't look Christmasy at all and it really draws your eye in to the entry. Love it!

  10. It looks great! I didn't know you lived in AZ. what area of town are you? Most houses here are cookie cutter and brown :/

  11. So BEAUTIFUL! You are so so talented and inspiring. You should start a kickstarter to fund your roof. I would definitely donate some just to see your full vision of the house come to fruition! haha and I know you said you don't want to, but maybe down the road those bricks can be painted white?? Regardless, the house exterior looks so amazing right now.

© Jenny Komenda. All Rights Reserved.
Site by